Friday, June 10, 2016

Initial Thoughts on the Differences Between Knitting and Crochet

I've finally reached the point in knitting where I feel like I understand the process and the stitches (for the most part). It's common for folks to compare the two and make various statements about their differences. Ideas about which is "better" for one thing or another can spark controversy. For my part, I'd like to share my thoughts about the differences, strengths, and weaknesses of each craft thus far. I do have a bit of a bias toward crochet, but I'll endeavor to keep my bias out of it. The following is all opinion based but may be of use to you as you decide which craft to use for what purpose.


It's easier to crochet in the round than knit in the round.
To crochet in the round all you need is a crochet hook and knowledge of how to get started. To knit in the round you need special needles, either double pointed needles or circular needles that are connected with a cable. It's easy to start round crochet projects, even as a beginner. Knitting in the round was a little bit harder for me to start for the first time than when I started crocheting in the round. Also, starting hats from the top down means more wiggle room for sizing. In knitting, you generally start from the brim and go up.

It's easier to create various shapes in crochet, especially for toys and dolls.
Shaping in crochet is easier to do. Only one stitch is active at a time, giving you lots of freedom. In knitting you have to think ahead a lot more when it comes to creating specific shapes and plan how to achieve them.

Knitted fabric truly is more flexible.
There's a lot you can do by changing your hook size and yarn, but the structure of knitted stitches simply makes a more flexible fabric than crochet stitches do. This is why knitted fabric is heavily preferred for garments. Crochet can make some beautiful clothes, for sure, but the fabric characteristics are different.

It's easier to work with thinner yarns in knitting.
So far it has been much easier on my hands to work with fingering weight yarn in knitting rather than crochet. This is because tension is different in knitting and far less controlled than in crochet. In crochet the tension is basically all on you. In knitting the needles do a lot of the work.

It's way easier to fix a mistake in crochet.
Even if your mistake was rows and rows back, you can just rip out your stitches and correct it. In knitting you have to reactivate all of the stitches in the row with the mistake, an annoying and precise process. Also, a dropped stitch in crochet is usually not a big deal and can even be fudged or ignored. In knitting, the dropped stitch will just keep dropping down the work and create a problem. I've made some large crochet errors before, but even the smallest knitting error irritates me way more.

Knitting uses less yarn.
Knitting does use about a third less yarn than crochet on average. It's not a big deal, but it might be important when you only have one skein. However...

Crochet grows much faster and gives you a sense of completion sooner.
I'm not a particularly quick crocheter, but spending several hours crocheting can make me feel like I've really gotten something done. I had barely picked up my hook before I had my upcoming crochet bag pattern complete. In contrast, I feel like I could knit all day and still barely have a few inches. The difference in the height of the stitches just makes knitting grow more slowly.

Details and finishing touches are more easily achieved in crochet.
I also think that they are prettier. I recently made a knitted cowl with a picot edge. I had to knit an extra eight rounds on both the top and bottom in order to achieve it. A picot edge in crochet is easy peasy. Also, you have to think about your edges way earlier in knitting or make them as separate pieces and sew them on. In crochet, you don't have to worry about your borders at all until the very end. Pretty lace add-ons and appliques are also simple to put together in crochet. Those things take longer and are harder to make when knitting.

As you can see, there are pros and cons to each craft. However, I don't think one is better than the other. They are different and are both useful and wonderful. As long as you keep your end goal in mind, you'll be able to decide which craft is right for you or your project. I encourage all of you crocheters out there to try knitting and all of you knitters to pick up a hook!

PS: Here's my crochet bias finally coming out... Did you know that in knitting you are sometimes instructed to use a crochet hook to fix mistakes, to add beads, or to seam? I don't recall ever having been asked to use knitting needles in my crochet :p

3 comments:

  1. I crochet.....self taught a few years ago at 50ish.....and enjoy it. I recently taught myself the basics of knitting. I find it to be much more complicated. The fabric that is produced with knitting is much more fluid, more fabric-like than what I can produce with crochet. But, as I'm not into making clothing with either knitting or crocheting, that's not a huge factor in which craft I prefer. The mistake factor figures more prominently with me. I find it miserably hard and frustrating to fix a mistake in knitting and relatively easy to do so in crochet. Since I use handwork to relax, keep my hands busy and to destress and calm myself, I doubt that I will ever find the same enjoyment with knitting that I do with crochet. Regrettably I might add as I do find knitted fabric quite beautiful.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks for sharing your perspective, Kim! I wonder if our shared preference for crochet comes partially as a result of learning it first? I suppose we will never no. I'm right there with you on the mistake-fixing thing!

      Delete
  2. I'm sure that which craft you learn first is a factor in preference. I've often thought that preference comes down to what you most desire to create and how patient you are. Do those who wish to make clothing prefer knitting for itself or because it is more conducive to clothes making? Do I prefer crochet because I like it better than knitting or is it because I'm impatient and crochet gives me results much more quickly? Knitting is very soothing to me if I'm doing a simple, simple stitch pattern. But after I've been knitting for two hours and have only created a few inches of fabric.....well, I can't imagine being patient enough to make an entire knitted Afghan, lol! So any knitting I do will likely be a scarf and I'll keep to crochet for the big stuff!

    ReplyDelete

Please share! Note that due to spam moderation there is a delay in comment posting.